Fences, walls and hedges can all be used to define the perimeter of a garden. But which is the better garden boundary? This post compares all three options and their pros and cons.
This is a collaborative post.
Why choose fencing?
Fencing is the most popular and versatile option. You can build a fence out of various materials including wood, metal or HDPE. Each material has its own unique properties. However, there are some pros and cons that apply to all types of fencing.
Pros
- Fencing is generally the most affordable option and is the easiest and quickest to install (although you may still want to hire a fencing company).
- You can buy fencing in many different styles and customise it in all kinds of colours.
- Tall panel fencing can offer great privacy, while lattice and picket fencing can still allow views and sunlight.
Cons
- Cheaper types of fencing won’t last as long as other boundary types and are vulnerable in a storm.
- Wooden and metal fencing require regular maintenance to keep them attractive and durable.
- Fencing may offer less security than other forms of garden boundary.
Why choose walls?
Walls provide a more permanent and robust barrier. You can build garden walls out of brick, stone or concrete. Brick tends to be the most common choice – there are a few different styles of brick that you can also choose from.
Pros
- Walls are the most solid and durable option – withstanding even the most extreme UK weather.
- If you want to reduce noise, walls can make an effective sound-insulating barrier.
- Walls are hard to climb and can make a great deterrent against intruders.
Cons
- Walls can cost a lot of money to install compared to other solutions.
- Walls can also take a lot of time to install and may require professional assistance.
- Compared to other boundary types, walls are harder to move or remove once installed.
Why choose hedges?
Hedges serve as a living wall. They are an eco-friendly option that can be constructed out of a range of different plants including leafy options like boxwood and yew and flowering options like escallonia and hydrangea.
Pros
- Hedges can help to support local wildlife including birds, insects and even small mammals like hedgehogs.
- Hedges bring a natural beauty to any garden – in some cases, adding bursts of colour with flowers or even producing fruit.
- A hedge can offer a lot of privacy and also help muffle noise.
Cons
- Hedges are the most high-maintenance garden boundary option – requiring annual pruning and regular watering during a drought.
- When planting a new hedge, you will need to wait for it to grow and nature in order to serve as an effective barrier.
- Although it depends on the plant and how far you cut it back, hedges generally take up more space than fences or walls.
Fence, wall or hedge?
There is no right option when it comes to choosing a garden boundary. The best solution for you will depend on your needs and how much money you have. Fencing is a good choice for those who want affordability, quick installation and simplicity. Walls are suited for those who want durability, security and noise reduction. Hedges are the best option for those who are environmentally conscious and green-fingered.