Malbec and Merlot are two of the most popular and approachable red wines, but they do not taste exactly the same. Although both can be smooth, fruity and very enjoyable, Malbec is usually the bolder and more intense wine, while Merlot tends to be softer, rounder and easier drinking.
The simplest way to choose between them is:
- Choose Malbec if you enjoy full-bodied red wine, dark fruit, spice and a little more tannin.
- Maybe select Merlot if you prefer something smoother, softer and dominated by ripe plum and cherry flavours.
- I suggest a Malbec with steak, lamb or barbecued food.
- Merlot goes nicely with roast chicken, pasta, pizza or mushroom dishes.
I enjoy both wines and find them very palatable compared with some more aggressively tannic reds. However, if I were ordering a bottle to accompany steak at an Argentinian restaurant, Malbec would almost certainly win.
Malbec vs Merlot
| Characteristic | Malbec | Merlot |
|---|---|---|
| Typical body | Full-bodied | Medium to full-bodied |
| Sweetness | Usually dry | Usually dry |
| Tannins | Medium to high | Usually softer and medium |
| Acidity | Typically medium | Typically medium |
| Main fruit flavours | Blackberry, black cherry and plum | Plum, cherry and blackberry |
| Other common notes | Violet, cocoa, spice, tobacco and vanilla | Chocolate, herbs, cedar and vanilla |
| Colour | Deep purple or inky red | Ruby red, becoming garnet with age |
| Best-known region | Mendoza, Argentina | Bordeaux, France |
| Best food matches | Steak, lamb and barbecue | Chicken, pasta, duck and mushrooms |
| Best for | People who enjoy bold reds | People who prefer smoother reds |
These are general characteristics rather than strict rules. You’ll find that the flavour of a wine is influenced by its climate, region, ripeness, winemaking and time spent in oak.
A ripe Merlot from a warm region can be more powerful than a lighter Malbec, while a traditional Malbec from Cahors in France can taste more structured and tannic than a fruitier Argentinian example.
What Is the Main Difference Between Malbec and Merlot?
The most noticeable difference is usually their structure. You’ll find that a Malbec commonly feels darker, bolder and more concentrated, with black-fruit flavours and firmer tannins. Compare with a Merlot which is generally rounder and softer, with ripe plum and cherry flavours.
Tannins are the compounds that create a dry or slightly grippy sensation in your mouth—rather like drinking strong black tea. A wine with more noticeable tannin can feel more structured, while a low-tannin wine generally feels softer.
This is why Merlot is often recommended to people beginning to explore red wine. However, many modern Argentinian Malbecs are also made in an accessible, fruit-forward style.
What Does Malbec Taste Like?
Malbec is generally a dry, full-bodied red wine. Common flavours and aromas include:
- Blackberry
- Black cherry
- Plum
- Blueberry
- Violet
- Cocoa or dark chocolate
- Black pepper and other spices
- Tobacco
- Vanilla from oak ageing
Argentinian Malbec is often rich and fruit-forward, with ripe dark-fruit flavours and a smooth or velvety texture. Mendoza is particularly famous for the grape.
Malbec originally came from France and remains closely associated with Cahors in south-west France. French Malbec can be earthier and more firmly tannic, with darker savoury characteristics alongside the fruit.
If you have tried one Malbec and found it either too heavy or too sharp, it is worth trying one from a different region. A French Malbec and an Argentinian Malbec can give you quite different drinking experiences.
What Does Merlot Taste Like?
I find that a Merlot is usually a dry, medium-to-full-bodied red wine with relatively soft tannins. Typical flavours include:
- Plum
- Red cherry
- Black cherry
- Blackberry
- Chocolate
- Dried herbs
- Cedar
- Tobacco
- Vanilla or baking spice from oak
You’ll find that Merlot grown in a cooler climate can show fresher red-fruit and herbal notes. Warmer-climate versions tend to be riper, fruitier and richer, sometimes with flavours reminiscent of chocolate or fruit cake.
Merlot is one of the principal grapes used in Bordeaux wine. It is particularly important on Bordeaux’s Right Bank, where it is frequently blended with Cabernet Franc and sometimes Cabernet Sauvignon.
It is also produced as a single-variety wine in countries including Chile, the United States, Australia, South Africa and New Zealand.
Are Malbec and Merlot Both Dry Wines?
Yes. The overwhelming majority of Malbec and Merlot wines are dry.
A dry wine contains very little residual sugar after fermentation. However, ripe fruit flavours and vanilla from oak can make a wine seem slightly sweet even when it is technically dry.
Merlot may sometimes taste sweeter because of its soft tannins and ripe plum flavours. Similarly, a warm-climate Malbec can taste very fruity without actually containing much sugar.
If sweetness matters to you, check the bottle description rather than assuming one grape will always be sweeter than the other.
Is Malbec Stronger Than Merlot?
Malbec often tastes stronger because it is typically fuller-bodied and more tannic, but this does not necessarily mean it contains more alcohol.
You’ll find that both Malbec and Merlot sit somewhere around 13% to 15% alcohol by volume, although individual bottles can fall outside this range. The label will give you the exact alcohol percentage.
The region and winemaking style matter more than the grape name alone. A powerful Merlot from a warm climate could contain more alcohol than a relatively restrained Malbec.
Which Is Smoother: Malbec or Merlot?
Merlot is usually the smoother of the two.
Its softer tannins and rounded plum flavours make it feel gentle and velvety. This can make Merlot a good choice for someone who finds some red wines too drying or bitter.
Malbec can also be wonderfully smooth, particularly when produced in Argentina, but it generally has more weight and structure. You may notice a firmer, slightly drier sensation after each sip.
If you are choosing wine for a group whose preferences you do not know, Merlot is often the safer crowd-pleaser. If your guests enjoy bold red wine, Malbec may be the more interesting option.
Malbec vs Merlot With Steak
Malbec is normally my first choice with steak. It pairs so well! Yummy.
Its dark fruit, spice and tannin work particularly well with the richness and charred flavours of grilled beef. This is one reason Malbec and Argentinian steakhouses have become such a familiar combination.
I’ve enjoyed some delicious Malbec at Buenos Aires in Maidstone, where it is an obvious partner for the restaurant’s Argentinian steaks.
Merlot can still work with steak, especially if it is a richer, full-bodied example. It may be preferable with a leaner cut, mushroom sauce or less heavily charred meat.
The verdict: Choose Malbec for a richly flavoured or chargrilled steak. Choose a full-bodied Merlot if you want something softer.
Best Food Pairings for Malbec
Malbec works especially well with strongly flavoured, roasted, grilled or smoky dishes.
I think good Malbec pairings include:
- Grilled steak
- Beef burgers
- Barbecued ribs
- Roast lamb
- Lamb chops
- Beef stew
- Empanadas
- Sausages
- Portobello mushrooms
- Hard cheeses
- Foods seasoned with pepper, paprika or smoky spices
The tannins in Malbec are softened by foods containing protein and fat, while its fruit and spice complement grilled flavours.
Malbec would work well alongside a rich beef bourguignon, although the traditional choice for cooking the dish would be a red Burgundy.
It is also a lovely addition to a grazing board with mature cheddar, Manchego and cured meats. My comparison of Serrano ham and Iberico ham may help you choose what to include.
Best Food Pairings for Merlot
Merlot is very versatile because it combines ripe fruit with relatively soft tannins.
Good Merlot pairings include:
- Roast chicken
- Roast turkey
- Duck
- Pork
- Spaghetti Bolognese
- Lasagne
- Pizza
- Meatballs
- Mushroom risotto
- Grilled vegetables
- Burgers
- Mild and medium-strength cheeses
I also think that a lighter Merlot can work with roast chicken or pork, while a richer example will stand up to beef, duck and tomato-based pasta dishes.
Merlot’s earthy fruit flavours are particularly good with mushrooms. It would be an approachable choice with a creamy pumpkin risotto, especially if the dish also contains mushrooms or herbs.
Can You Drink Malbec or Merlot Without Food?
Both can be enjoyed without food, although Merlot is often easier to drink on its own because its tannins tend to be softer.
If you want a relaxed glass of red wine without planning a meal, look for a fruit-forward Merlot or an Argentinian Malbec described as smooth, supple or velvety.
A very tannic Malbec may taste slightly harsh without food. Allowing it to breathe or serving it with some of your favourite cheese can make it feel softer.
Malbec can also make a lovely wine for an evening around the campfire. If you are planning a trip, these camping lunch ideas include plenty of options that could be adapted into an evening picnic or grazing board.
Should You Decant Malbec or Merlot?
Young, full-bodied Malbec can benefit from being opened or decanted around 30 to 60 minutes before drinking. Exposure to air can help its aromas emerge and make the tannins feel a little softer.
Everyday Merlot does not normally need lengthy decanting, although opening it 15 to 30 minutes before serving may help. Older bottles need more careful handling because they can lose their aromas if left exposed for too long.
You do not need an elaborate decanter. Pouring the wine into a clean glass jug can perform the same basic function.
What Temperature Should Malbec and Merlot Be Served At?
Both wines are best served slightly cooler than a typical centrally heated room.
A temperature of approximately 15–18°C generally works well. If your bottle has been sitting in a warm kitchen, placing it in the fridge for 20 to 30 minutes before serving can improve it considerably.
You’ll find that serving red wine too warm can make the alcohol seem more noticeable. On the opposite side, serving it very cold can suppress the fruit and make the tannins feel harsher.
How to Choose a Bottle of Malbec
When shopping for Malbec, look at the country and region.
For a ripe and approachable style:
Look for Malbec from Mendoza in Argentina. These wines commonly offer generous dark fruit and relatively rounded tannins.
For something fresher or more refined:
Try a high-altitude Argentinian Malbec, perhaps from the Uco Valley. Cooler nights can help the grapes retain freshness.
For a firmer, more savoury wine:
Choose Malbec from Cahors in France. It may require food or a little more time to breathe.
Words such as “oak-aged”, “reserve” or “barrel selection” can suggest additional vanilla, toast and spice, although these terms do not guarantee quality.
How to Choose a Bottle of Merlot
Merlot’s style also depends heavily on where it was grown.
For a soft, fruity and affordable option:
Look for Merlot from Chile, Australia or another warm New World region.
For a more structured wine:
Look for a Bordeaux blend containing a high proportion of Merlot.
For a richer style:
Choose a bottle described as full-bodied or oak-aged, with black-fruit and chocolate notes.
If you want Merlot rather than a blend, check the front and back labels. A bottle of Bordeaux may contain mostly Merlot without displaying the grape name prominently.
Malbec vs Merlot for Beginners
I would say a glass of Merlot is probably the better starting point for someone completely new to red wine because it is generally soft, fruity and not overly tannic.
However, an inexpensive Argentinian Malbec can be equally approachable and may appeal more to someone who already enjoys strong flavours, black coffee or dark chocolate.
My beginner’s rule would be:
- Start with Merlot if you want smooth and mellow.
- Start with Malbec if you want rich and bold.
- Try both alongside food if you are unsure.
The best wine is ultimately the one you genuinely enjoy. Even professional food-pairing guidance begins with choosing a wine that suits your own palate, as explained in these WSET food and wine pairing principles.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, Malbec or Merlot?
Neither is universally better. Malbec is better for drinkers who like bold, full-bodied reds, while Merlot generally suits those who prefer something smooth and rounded.
Is Malbec more full-bodied than Merlot?
Usually, yes. Malbec is commonly full-bodied, whereas Merlot ranges from medium to full-bodied. However, the region and winemaking style can reverse that comparison.
Does Malbec have more tannins than Merlot?
Malbec generally has firmer and more noticeable tannins. Merlot is known for its comparatively soft, rounded texture.
Is Malbec or Merlot sweeter?
Both are normally dry. Merlot can appear sweeter because of its ripe plum flavour and softer tannins, but the actual sugar content depends on the individual wine.
Which wine is better with steak?
Malbec is the classic choice, particularly with a chargrilled or richly flavoured steak. A full-bodied Merlot can also work well, especially with mushroom sauce.
Which wine is easier to drink?
Merlot is generally easier for new red-wine drinkers because it tends to have softer tannins. A smooth Argentinian Malbec is another accessible option.
Can Malbec and Merlot be blended together?
Yes. Both grapes originated in France and can appear together in blends. Malbec was historically one of the grapes used in Bordeaux, although Merlot is now much more prominent there.
Which has more calories, Malbec or Merlot?
The difference is normally small. Alcohol level, residual sugar and serving size have more influence on calories than whether the wine is Malbec or Merlot.
Malbec vs Merlot
Choose Malbec when you want a bold, dark and full-bodied wine to accompany steak, lamb, barbecue or strongly flavoured food.
Choose Merlot when you want a softer and smoother red that can accompany everything from roast chicken and pasta to mushrooms and pizza.
For me, Malbec wins when there is steak involved, while Merlot is the more versatile bottle to open for a relaxed evening or mixed group. Both are approachable red wines, and trying them side by side is probably the most enjoyable way to discover which one you prefer.
Whichever you choose, serve it slightly cooler than room temperature and enjoy it responsibly.

